The Institute of Canine Biology
  • HOME
  • Blog
  • Courses
    • COI BootCamp (FREE!)
    • Basic Population Genetics (FREE)
    • The Science of Canine Husbandry
    • Managing Genetics For the Future >
      • Syllabus - Managing Genetics for the Future
    • The Biology of Dogs (Open Reg )
    • DNA For Dog Breeders >
      • Syllabus - DNA for Dog Breeders
      • Open Reg - DNA For Dog Breeders
    • Understanding Hip & Elbow Dysplasia >
      • Open Reg - Understanding Hip & Elbow Dysplasia
    • Genetics of Behavior & Performance >
      • Syllabus - Genetics Behavior & Performance
      • Open Reg - Genetics of Behavior & Performance (Open Reg)
    • Strategies for Preservation Breeding >
      • Open Reg - Strategies for Preservation Breeding
    • Group Discounts
    • MORE FREE COURSES >
      • Quickie Genetics (Free!)
      • Heredity & Genetics (Free!)
      • Useful Genetics (Free!)
      • Basic Genetics Videos
  • Breed Preservation
    • Breed Status
    • Breeding for the future >
      • BFF Breed Groups
    • The "Elevator Pitch"
    • What's in the Gene Pool?
    • The Pox of Popular Sires
    • What population genetics can tell us about a breed
    • What population genetics can tell you...Tollers & Heelers
    • How to use kinship data
    • Using EBVs to breed better dogs >
      • How population size affects inbreeding
      • EBV Examples
    • How to read a dendrogram
    • Global Pedigree Project >
      • The Database
    • Finding the genes without DNA
    • How to read a heat map
  • Health Data
    • Bloat (Purdue Study)
    • Body Condition Score >
      • % Dysplastic vs BCS
    • Breed Comparions
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Cataracts
    • Caesareans
    • Deafness
    • Degenerative Myelopathy
    • Elbow Dysplasia
    • Epilepsy
    • Genetic Diversity
    • Genetic Diversity (MyDogDNA)
    • Hip Dysplasia >
      • Hip Dysplasia (Hou et al 2013)
    • Inbreeding Effects
    • Inbreeding (Gubbels)
    • Inbreeding (Dreger)
    • Lifespan
    • Litter size
    • Metabolic
    • mtDNA
    • Orthopedic
    • Mode of Inheritance
    • Patella Luxation
    • Thyroid
    • Portosystemic shunt
    • Purebred vs Mixed (UC Davis)
    • Purebred vs Mixed Breed (Bonnett)
    • Spay & Neuter Effects
    • Calboli et al 2008
    • Hodgman (1963)
    • Scott & Fuller (1965)
    • Stockard: Purebred crosses
    • Summers (2011)
  • Projects
    • How To Interpret Breed Analyses
    • Afghan Hound
    • More details about the Toller study
    • Belgian Tervuren >
      • Belgian Terv p2
      • Belgians- why population size matters
    • Bernese Mountain Dog
    • Boxer
    • Brussels Griffon
    • Bullmastiff
    • Canaan Dog >
      • Canaan analyses
    • Cesky Terrier >
      • Cesky genetic history
    • Chinook
    • Curly-coated Retriever
    • Doberman
    • Entelbucher Mountain Dog
    • Flatcoat Retriever
    • French Bulldog
    • German Shorthair
    • Golden Retriever >
      • Golden Retriever Pedigree Charts
    • Irish Water Spaniel >
      • IWS (6 Nov 17)
    • Labrador Retriever
    • Manchester Terrier
    • Mongolian Bankhar >
      • Research Updates
      • Bankhar 1
    • Norwegian Lundehund
    • Plummer Terrier
    • Otterhound
    • Portuguese Water Dog >
      • Portuguese Water Dog (pt 2)
    • Ridgeback
    • Schipperke
    • Standard Poodle >
      • The Problem With Poodles
      • 3poodle pedigree charts
      • 3Poodle Wycliff dogs
      • Poodle Genetics
    • Tibetan Spaniel
    • Tibetan Mastiff
    • West Highland White Terrier
    • Whippet
    • Wirehaired Pointing Griffons
    • UK KC Graphs >
      • UK KC Breed Status
      • UK Groups
      • KC Gundogs
      • KC Hounds
      • KC Terriers >
        • Terriers (select breeds)
      • KC Pastoral
      • KC Toys
      • KC Working
      • KC Utility
      • Australian KC
    • Breed outcrossing programs
  • Resources
    • Genetics Databases
    • Stud Books >
      • American Kennel Club stud books
      • Field Dog stud books
      • The Kennel Club (UK)
    • Learn
    • Videos about dog genetics
    • The Amazing Things Dogs Do! (videos) >
      • Livestock Management
      • Livestock guarding
      • Transportation, exploration, racing
      • Conservation & wildlife management
      • Detection Dogs
      • Medicine & Research
      • Entertainment
      • AKC/CHF Podcasts
    • Read & Watch
    • Bookshelf
  • Preventing Uterine Inertia

About pithy statements vs knowledge

8/15/2019

 
By Carol Beuchat, PhD
As breeders become more aware of the importance for genetic management to control potential genetic disorders, there are more and more discussions in groups about the best ways to do this. Little bits of information, packaged as what I think of as "pithy statements", are put forth as rules of thumb, and these are advocated as best practices. 

Somebody told me the other day that their group was thinking about making a rule prohibiting breedings that would produce COI > 10%, because they heard that 10% was the threshold of the "extinction vortex". She asked me if I thought this was a good idea.

This 10% extinction vortex statement is one of those pithy statements.

I advised her that breeders should NOT make a rule about this. Not because it's not true, but because "it's complicated."
First, with the tools we currently have, inbreeding can only be estimated. From a pedigree database, we can only get an estimate for a litter, not for individual animals. This is because a COI calculated from pedigree information is based on the genetic relatedness of the parents. All puppies in a litter have the same parents, but each will inherit different genes from each parent so will have a different actual level of inbreeding. The pedigree COI is an estimate of the average inbreeding expected for a litter, but the actual inbreeding for each individual can be higher or lower than that average. For that reason alone, it would be silly to declare 10% as a hard cutoff for breedings.

Second, inbreeding is only one of many things breeders should consider when making breeding decisions. Animals not bred are effectively removed from the gene pool, and a smaller gene pool, as well as fewer breeding animals, will result in a higher rate of inbreeding in the population - which is the very thing you were trying to avoid. You might be better off producing litters with higher inbreeding than strictly abiding by a rule that could result in negative consequences over the longer term.
Picture
You also need to consider which animals are most "valuable" genetically in the breed. These won't be the progeny of the top winning popular sire. All of these animals are related to each other as half-sibs and will share many genes from their common sire. These dogs are less valuable because they are all so similar. The valuable dogs in the breed are the ones that carry genes that are uncommon. These might be from small kennels, or old lines, or isolated in another country, or just not the most popular type. Not breeding these animals risks losing their less common genomes from the breed and making the gene pool smaller. In contrast, not breeding one of the many half-sibs of the popular sire is unlikely to reduce his representation in the gene pool because his genes are carried by so many  animals. 

There are other things to consider in making breeding decisions such as the carrier status of an animal for a known genetic mutation, or the balance of males and females in the population that are bred. In any breed,, there might be many issues that are critical to consider because of their potential longer-term impact on the genetics of the breed.

It's great that breeders are beginning to consider aspects of genetic management like the the risk of getting sucked into the extinction vortex as inbreeding increases above 10%. But beware of reducing what should be a complex set of genetic considerations to a simple rule. There is much more to consider, and the more you learn, the more you will realize how dangerous it is to make complicated decisions based on a pithy statement.

You can learn more about the genetics of dogs in ICB's online courses.
Check out ICB's course "COI Bootcamp"

*** Visit our Facebook pages ***

ICB Institute of Canine Biology
...the latest canine news and research

ICB Breeding for the Future
...the science of animal breeding


Comments are closed.

    Archives

    January 2025
    November 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    December 2020
    January 2020
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    October 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    March 2013
    July 2012
    April 2012

    Categories

    All
    Behavior
    Border-collie
    Herding

Blog

News


About Us

Contact Us








Copyright © 2012-2017 Institute of Canine Biology
Picture
Picture