The Institute of Canine Biology
  • HOME
  • Blog
  • Courses
    • COI BootCamp (FREE!)
    • Basic Population Genetics (FREE)
    • The Science of Canine Husbandry
    • Managing Genetics For the Future >
      • Syllabus - Managing Genetics for the Future
    • The Biology of Dogs (Open Reg )
    • DNA For Dog Breeders >
      • Syllabus - DNA for Dog Breeders
      • Open Reg - DNA For Dog Breeders
    • Understanding Hip & Elbow Dysplasia >
      • Open Reg - Understanding Hip & Elbow Dysplasia
    • Genetics of Behavior & Performance >
      • Syllabus - Genetics Behavior & Performance
      • Open Reg - Genetics of Behavior & Performance (Open Reg)
    • Strategies for Preservation Breeding >
      • Open Reg - Strategies for Preservation Breeding
    • Group Discounts
    • MORE FREE COURSES >
      • Quickie Genetics (Free!)
      • Heredity & Genetics (Free!)
      • Useful Genetics (Free!)
      • Basic Genetics Videos
  • Breed Preservation
    • Breed Status
    • Breeding for the future >
      • BFF Breed Groups
    • The "Elevator Pitch"
    • What's in the Gene Pool?
    • The Pox of Popular Sires
    • What population genetics can tell us about a breed
    • What population genetics can tell you...Tollers & Heelers
    • How to use kinship data
    • Using EBVs to breed better dogs >
      • How population size affects inbreeding
      • EBV Examples
    • How to read a dendrogram
    • Global Pedigree Project >
      • The Database
    • Finding the genes without DNA
    • How to read a heat map
  • Health Data
    • Bloat (Purdue Study)
    • Body Condition Score >
      • % Dysplastic vs BCS
    • Breed Comparions
    • Cancer
    • Cardiac
    • Cataracts
    • Caesareans
    • Deafness
    • Degenerative Myelopathy
    • Elbow Dysplasia
    • Epilepsy
    • Genetic Diversity
    • Genetic Diversity (MyDogDNA)
    • Hip Dysplasia >
      • Hip Dysplasia (Hou et al 2013)
    • Inbreeding Effects
    • Inbreeding (Gubbels)
    • Inbreeding (Dreger)
    • Lifespan
    • Litter size
    • Metabolic
    • mtDNA
    • Orthopedic
    • Mode of Inheritance
    • Patella Luxation
    • Thyroid
    • Portosystemic shunt
    • Purebred vs Mixed (UC Davis)
    • Purebred vs Mixed Breed (Bonnett)
    • Spay & Neuter Effects
    • Calboli et al 2008
    • Hodgman (1963)
    • Scott & Fuller (1965)
    • Stockard: Purebred crosses
    • Summers (2011)
  • Projects
    • How To Interpret Breed Analyses
    • Afghan Hound
    • More details about the Toller study
    • Belgian Tervuren >
      • Belgian Terv p2
      • Belgians- why population size matters
    • Bernese Mountain Dog
    • Boxer
    • Brussels Griffon
    • Bullmastiff
    • Canaan Dog >
      • Canaan analyses
    • Cesky Terrier >
      • Cesky genetic history
    • Chinook
    • Curly-coated Retriever
    • Doberman
    • Entelbucher Mountain Dog
    • Flatcoat Retriever
    • French Bulldog
    • German Shorthair
    • Golden Retriever >
      • Golden Retriever Pedigree Charts
    • Irish Water Spaniel >
      • IWS (6 Nov 17)
    • Labrador Retriever
    • Manchester Terrier
    • Mongolian Bankhar >
      • Research Updates
      • Bankhar 1
    • Norwegian Lundehund
    • Plummer Terrier
    • Otterhound
    • Portuguese Water Dog >
      • Portuguese Water Dog (pt 2)
    • Ridgeback
    • Schipperke
    • Standard Poodle >
      • The Problem With Poodles
      • 3poodle pedigree charts
      • 3Poodle Wycliff dogs
      • Poodle Genetics
    • Tibetan Spaniel
    • Tibetan Mastiff
    • West Highland White Terrier
    • Whippet
    • Wirehaired Pointing Griffons
    • UK KC Graphs >
      • UK KC Breed Status
      • UK Groups
      • KC Gundogs
      • KC Hounds
      • KC Terriers >
        • Terriers (select breeds)
      • KC Pastoral
      • KC Toys
      • KC Working
      • KC Utility
      • Australian KC
    • Breed outcrossing programs
  • Resources
    • Genetics Databases
    • Stud Books >
      • American Kennel Club stud books
      • Field Dog stud books
      • The Kennel Club (UK)
    • Learn
    • Videos about dog genetics
    • The Amazing Things Dogs Do! (videos) >
      • Livestock Management
      • Livestock guarding
      • Transportation, exploration, racing
      • Conservation & wildlife management
      • Detection Dogs
      • Medicine & Research
      • Entertainment
      • AKC/CHF Podcasts
    • Read & Watch
    • Bookshelf
  • Preventing Uterine Inertia

The questions "PUPscan" won't answer. Part 2: The answers

3/1/2017

 
By Carol Beuchat PhD
Yesterday's post was about a new venture in the UK called "PUPscan", which endeavors to identify puppies that will develop hip dysplasia as adults on the basis of a sonographic examination of the hips in puppies 6-8 weeks old. The gist of my discussion is that I had basic questions about what they were measuring and the scientific evidence to support assertion that their scans would be predictive of hip dysplasia in the adult. They did not provide answers to these questions despite repeated attempts to extract basic information from them. 
  • What "measurements" are taken?
  • What evidence is there that whatever you are scoring is predictive of the development of hip dysplasia?
  • What value is there in imaging a cartilagenous joint that is yet to be formed?
  • What is the basis for your claim to be assessing "congenital genetic dysplasia"?​​

If you haven't already, you can read my earlier post here.
Last night, I was alerted to a paper (Fischer et al, 2010) that examined the efficacy of using ultrasound of puppies to predict hip dysplasia in adult dogs. ​This is the very thing they appear to be doing, so the results of that study are worth a closer look. 
They examined 566 puppies of 17 different breeds, from age 16 to 49 days (mean = 32.5 days). They clearly describe the measurements they made, which included α-angle (as illustrated), as well as a measure of joint laxity (distraction value, DV). They also assessed the repeatability of their measurements and subjected the data to rigorous statistical analysis. They note that they did not record β-angle as had been done in other studies because of low repeatability. Of the animals they examined as puppies, 203 (35.9%) were radiographed as adults for classification of hip status. 
Picture
Picture

Their results:

"...No statistical significant correlation could be found between sonographical determinations of α-angle, joint laxity, DV and conventional radiographic hip joint classification at the age of 12 to 24 months...None of the
parameters assessed by ultrasonography in puppies could ultimately be linked to adult CHD. 
Results of our study suggest that static and dynamic ultrasonography of hip joints in puppies between 16 and 49 days of age is technically feasible but cannot be recommended for detecting puppies that will develop CHD between the ages of 12 and 24 months."
Picture
Their conclusion is very clear. They were unable to predict the development of hip dysplasia based on ultrasound examination of young puppies. Further, they note that similar sonographic assessments have been done on newborn infants to detect dysplastic or immature hips for many years. However, they note that the hips of  puppies always appear normal at birth and dysplasia develops postnatally, so the structural anomalies in newborn infants are not evident until later development in puppies.
There is one question I asked that is not answered by this study: 

  • What is the basis for your claim to be assessing "congenital genetic dysplasia"?​​

PUPscan claims to be able to distinguish "genetic" dysplasia from dysplasia resulting from trauma or damage. In fact, as Riser et al (1985) explain, the hips of all puppies are anatomically normal at birth, and hip dysplasia is the consequence of abnormal stresses on the structures of the hip that result from laxity in the joint. That is, there is no "genetic" hip dysplasia in which genes are responsible for misshaping of the hip during post-natal development. Rather, hip dysplasia is in fact the result of trauma and damage because of abnormal biomechanics. He notes that genetics does play a role in the body conformation of a dog (e.g., size, weight, muscle development), and these features are related to breed-specific differences in the prevalence of hip dysplasia, with large, heavy dogs being at highest risk. From this, 
To be fair, assessing joint laxity in young puppies seems like a reasonable idea. In fact, I've given it some thought myself, and I haven't ruled out the possibility that it might be a useful thing to do. While this study failed to find that any of the things they measured were predictive, it's possible that focusing on a single breed (instead of combining the results from 17 breeds) might reveal something missed in this study. 
The bottom line

A published, peer-reviewed study failed to find any evidence that ultrasound examination of young puppies was predictive of the development of hip dysplasia as adults.

Finally, this post appeared on the PUPscan Facebook page today:
Picture


REFERENCES

Fischer A, A Flock, B Tellhelm, K Failing, M Kramer, & C Thiel. 2010. Static and dynamic ultrasonography for the early diagnosis of canine hip dysplasia. Journal of Small Animal Practice 51: 582-588. DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-5827.2010.00995.x.

Riser WH, WH Rhodes, & CD Newton. 1985. Hip dysplasia. Ch 83 in Textbook of Small Animal Orthopedics, CD Newton, Ed. Lippencott Williams & Wilkins. 




Check out
ICB's online courses
​

*******************

Join our Facebook Group
ICB Breeding for the Future
...the science of dog breeding
*******************

Visit our Facebook Page
ICB Institute of Canine Biology
...the latest canine news and research
​


Comments are closed.

    Archives

    January 2025
    November 2022
    July 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    December 2020
    January 2020
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    October 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    February 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    March 2013
    July 2012
    April 2012

    Categories

    All
    Behavior
    Border-collie
    Herding

Blog

News


About Us

Contact Us








Copyright © 2012-2017 Institute of Canine Biology
Picture
Picture